Enjoy this conversation with Josh Bressers, product security at Elastic and former colleague at Red Hat. Josh answers my questions about password management, general computer security and what matters (or doesn’t) in today’s predominantly online world.

 

Discussion Highlights

  • How John and Josh met at Red Hat
  • Reliving the old days of testing and releasing security updates
  • Considering overall return on investment (ROI) of your approach to security
  • How do we know that these password managers are really secure? We can’t know with complete certainty
  • What happens if your password manager is compromised and how you would recover?
  • Ultimately you can’t control where your data is stored when you enter “the cloud”
  • Lastpass and 1Password appear to be the leading solutions
  • Backup schemes and philosophies
  • Understanding two factor authentication and its benefits
  • Duo Security
  • “Good enough” vs. “perfect” security
  • Yubikey 4 (two-factor authentication token)
  • You have to draw a line somewhere when you plan around all of the “what if” scenarios of something going bad or getting compromised
  • Making decisions in a way that results in a “hard yes”
  • How becoming a product manager opened Josh’s eyes to the downside of complexity and the importance of practicality
  • Josh’s preference for locked down devices like the iPhone, iPad and Google Chrome Books
  • Dropbox is not secure as some people think

Learn More about Josh Bressers

Credits

All songs licensed under Creative Commons

Transcript

This transcript was created automatically and may contain small errors.

John: Alright. Today I wanted to welcome Josh Bressers to the podcast. Josh, who are you and what are you up to?

Josh: Oh man, I ask myself that every day, John. It’s— yeah. So where should we start?

John: Well, we can start at the mothership. We met at Red Hat about like 13—

Josh: 200 years ago.

John: Yeah. So, so Josh was the Were you the number 2 security guy?

Josh: I was, yes.

John: The second in the history of Red Hat?

Josh: Maybe. I don’t— It

John: sounds important. I mean, there was—

Josh: I’d be uncomfortable saying that because I can’t really— I can’t back that up with any sort of facts, but it was long enough ago. There wasn’t like a team doing any security really.

John: It was you and one other person.

Josh: And I made it a team. Right. I was, I’m willing to say I was the second employee on the first team doing security at Red Hat because there were plenty of other people doing security.

John: Yeah. So I was responsible for testing all the updates to our only product, RHEL.

Josh: That’s right. You were the guy slowing us down, man. I remember that.

John: And yeah, we got into it a few times, but I would talk to Josh at least on a weekly basis because he would give me like, hey, we’ve got this important vulnerability. There were like 3 applications, Firefox, Thunderbird, and RealPlayer.

Josh: Remember RealPlayer? Oh, RealPlayer.

John: Whatever happened to that thing? Oh, yeah, they— It was like every week it was one of those.

Josh: They produced a ton. I’d forgotten all about RealPlayer, John, until just now when I had this, like, flood of terrible memories come into my mind. It was— ah, that thing was terrible.

John: I was asking someone the other day, whatever happened to RealPlayer? I think they’re still around, but I don’t know.

Josh: Oh, man.

John: Anyway, anyway, we— so, so you are a security guy. You did security at Red Hat. You’re not at Red Hat anymore. Where are you these days?

Josh: No, I’m at Elastic. I do similar things. I call myself the head of product security, where I do product management for security features and security of the products, as well as I help deal with the security updates in the products, when we, you know, all the CVEs and things like that that get released and fixed on a regular basis. Yeah, it’s good. It’s a cool place. We do Elasticsearch and the Elastic Stack, and it really is an amazing tool if you’ve never played with it. You can do some crazy things with your data and see what’s going on in near real time, which is awesome.

John: I saw something you— I was following you on Twitter, and you said something about passwords and stuff, and that got me to thinking about this problem that I’ve been trying to solve for the longest time that I’m wondering if you can help me solve today, and that has to do with password management.

Josh: Yeah.

John: Here’s the crux of my situation. I want to use a password manager. I don’t want to use something geeky like KDE, whatever, or what’s it, Kpax? Or there’s all these geeky Linuxy like things that people, especially inside Red Hat, just swear by. Like, this is the way you’re supposed to go. Well, my use case is I’m on a Mac. Uh, my wife has a Mac. I want her to be able to have all my super secret, super long passwords. I want to use unique passwords. If I’m on a trip and my plane never returns, or I’m in a coma or something, and she needs to get to my information, I still want to be secure. I want her to get to it. I know there’s LastPass, there’s 1Password, there’s these online things. Where do we start? What’s the headset that a normal person, technical enough to be dangerous like myself, can come at this with?

Josh: So if I put my tinfoil hat on, I’m going to tell you not to trust any of those people.

John: But that’s what I would’ve expected when I reached out to you. I was like, Josh is going to say, John, don’t go near any of

Josh: them. I would’ve said that a couple years ago without question, but I would say I’ve maybe acquired a real-world approach to security, we could say, where you can’t tell people things like that because if you tell them that, they quit listening to you, is what ends up happening. Right. So what I would tell you to do is just look at the features of these products and pick the one that ticks the boxes you need. For example, I am using LastPass for— granted, not all my passwords, but many of them— because it has something called LastPass Family. I can share passwords with my wife and kids. In the event, like you said, I get on the airplane and it doesn’t land, or it lands maybe more abruptly than expected, then my wife has the ability to get at my passwords, which is, in my opinion, a huge benefit. There are certainly drawbacks, but the reality is that the benefits outweigh the negatives probably 10 to 1, at least. Yes, let’s face it. If some 3-letter agency wants to come after me and steal my passwords, it probably doesn’t matter where I’m storing them, right? They’re going to get them. And so that’s one of the things, actually, that I’ve really started to embrace since I became a product manager some years ago. And obviously, return on investment is a big topic you have.

John: Absolutely.

Josh: Right, exactly. And so I started thinking about security kind of in an ROI perspective of if I’m doing everything offline, right, and I’ve got these crazy password managers and these crazy rules— I mean, I used to have— man, I could talk about how I used to deal with passwords, and I could write a book about the insane things I did. I realized at one point my return on investment was unquestionably negative because I was spending so much time and energy on a problem that, in all seriousness, wasn’t even real.

John: Even for yourself?

Josh: Even for me, yes, as much as I wish—

John: So if your plane had never landed, your wife would have been totally hosed?

Josh: Oh, no. I had a backup for that, but it was so complicated it’s quite likely she couldn’t have figured it out. But yes, I had a setup where my passwords— I still have instructions at the bank in my box with this crazy printout of like, here are 100 steps you have to do and then you can access my passwords. And it’s like, I’m going to— Oh, I love that. It was terrible. It was terrible, John.

John: I love that because I went on an international trip a year or two ago and I have my LastPass password at the time. I’ve changed my practices, but I’m curious for your advice here. 100 characters long, and I would copy and paste it in. And so I printed it out on a piece of paper and we made this little video and I was like, okay, if I don’t return, you take this, you have to take this 100-character thing and you have to get it into this thing. And then it went along. And so, yeah, but that, but I never like stored it anywhere safe or anything like that. So as a starting point though, what’s, what’s your minimum bar? So, okay. So LastPass, says that they encrypt everything and that they can’t read your stuff. How do we know that’s true?

Josh: We don’t. We don’t know that’s true. Look, it basically is because people have been looking at them, but fundamentally, there could unquestionably be a problem where somehow they could read your password. But here’s the reality. Here’s the way I look at this. Let’s say LastPass has access to all my passwords. What’s really the worst they’re going to do? Let’s say a bad guy gets a hold of all my passwords. What’s the worst that’s really going to happen? And you know what’s going to happen? My bank accounts will probably be emptied and maybe my credit cards will be maxed out or something, but here’s the deal. I can fix all that stuff. It will suck and it probably won’t happen, and I’m betting it won’t, which is why I’m willing to take some of these risks. Okay. And that’s kind of the way you look at it, right? Think of it as your return on investment. I could, I could continue doing crazy tinfoil hat things, and that will work, but it will drain me mentally, and it will take up my time. Yes. Because let’s face it, as I become an old man, my time is gaining in value immensely, right? Where I’m like, I don’t want to spend 6 hours every week working on this crap. I want to go play with my kids, or I want to go outside, or whatever, right? And so that’s part of it as well, is, is ease of use. is a big part of my story. But anyway, and here’s the thing. Let’s say everything gets compromised and let’s say a bad guy gets to all of my stuff before I figure it out and I can lock it down. I can fix it. It’ll probably take a week of my life, but I can fix it. And my suspicion—

John: Someone’s drained your bank account. How do you fix that?

Josh: You call your bank, man. It’s fraud. They have insurance for things like that. I mean, look, if someone basically breaks into your bank account and steals all your stuff, They’re gonna— it will take time, mind you, but you’ll get your money back.

John: Well, just to be clear, we’re not giving advice to anyone here.

Josh: Yes, I am not a lawyer.

John: We’re not lawyers. We are not giving advice. We are just having a conversation about different aspects of security here. So take everything you hear with a grain of salt.

Josh: Right, right. Yes, absolutely. But, but anyway, and that’s kind of the way I’ve been thinking about it, right?

John: So if I have a choice between— so I was also looking at 1Password, and I was attracted to 1Password because it would encrypt and store your stuff in Dropbox. And I was like, well, I like that because I could at least control where it’s stored. Is there any advantage there, or have I already wasted too much information or too much time thinking about it?

Josh: So here’s the thing. You can’t control where anything’s stored, whether you think you can or not. And this is kind of one of the, I guess, humorous things I see with modern computing is we love to talk about on-prem, and we love to talk about how we’re going to keep our data safe, and we’re going to control our data and all this stuff. But the reality is, if you’re using a modern device, you can’t say you’re I mean, how many things are running on this stuff? You probably have access to Dropbox from your phone, right, which you can probably unlock with a fingerprint or something. You can’t—

John: No, I don’t do that.

Josh: I do. It’s nice. It’s so convenient, though, John, and that’s the thing, right?

John: You really have come a long way.

Josh: I have. I have. I’m very proud of myself. I call myself— actually, it’s really funny, is when I go give talks at conferences, and I’m actually putting a lot of focus now giving talks at non-security conferences because the security conferences— That’s for you. You’re preaching to the choir, right? Or they think I’m insane because I’m not like them anymore. But I’ll tell people at a regular conference, like, I’m a recovering security person, and of course it gets a huge laugh. Right, right, right. But that’s kind of the intention, right? One of the feelings I have is that a lot of the security industry has failed by not taking normal people into account. They expect everyone to succumb to their rules instead of saying, how can we exist in your world and make your life better. And I think this is why a lot of security fails today is because we don’t take a practical approach. It’s a very, no, no, you listen to me or else. And when they’re like, screw you, I’m just going to take my credit card to Amazon, now what? Right now, now you have 2 problems instead of one.

John: And when you say take your credit card to Amazon, that’s like they’re spending— Yeah, right. Shadow IT, man, doing whatever they want.

Josh: Absolutely. And it happens all the time, right? It happens constantly and it costs like $10, right? For $10, you have infrastructure. It’s crazy. It’s amazing.

John: Right, right. So infrastructure, password infrastructure, for someone that wants to get started with this, isn’t sure where to go, like someone like me. So you look at, say, LastPass, 1Password. Are there any others that, that are worth considering or that you know about?

Josh: To be perfectly honest with you, I, I couldn’t even name them off the top of my head right now. It’s the 1Password and LastPass are kind of the 2 really big ones, and, and they work well, right? There’s— I, I don’t— I guess I haven’t found a reason to do a lot of exploring. I know there’s KeePassX, which is a local thing. There was something called Password Safe that I used to use, and that’s a local thing again. There’s a handful of other password storage companies, I guess, and there’s probably some services, whatever you want to call them. It’s one of those things, just look around, get a feel for what they do, and then pick the one that ticks the boxes you need. And that’s basically what it’s going to come down to.

John: And hold on to it loosely because it’s— because none of it’s failsafe.

Josh: It is not failsafe. And it’s probably more failsafe than keeping it on your local gear, though, for what it’s worth. Right. Because you’ve got to think most of these services are storing your data in some sort of cloud-like environment, whereas if your password safe is only on your laptop and your laptop is stolen or crashes, you no longer have a password safe.

John: Unless you back it up to somewhere else.

Josh: Right, exactly though. Exactly. It starts getting out of hand quickly when you start talking about that. And then you need— well, is your backup in your house? And like one of my favorite examples— so this is, I used to do this crazy backup scheme where I would have multiple hard drives and I would rotate them and keep some offsite and do this and that.

John: Yes, yes.

Josh: And I remember at one point I was thinking to myself, like, this is madness. This doesn’t make sense. But you figure if you back up your data into your basement and your house burns down, like that backup Exactly. And so you need to think about all this stuff. Exactly. This is tricky stuff, man. I guess this is the beauty of where we exist today in computing. There’s so many things as a service now. I mean, I look at Gmail. I use Gmail for my email. I remember there was a time when I was like, oh, I’m never going to give Google my email. Then I got old and thought, whatever. I’m too tired and lazy.

John: Let them read everything.

Josh: Seriously, man. That’s part of it, absolutely. But here’s the thing to remember. Is Google reading my email? Maybe. Do I care? You know what? I don’t because they already have access to most of it anyway because the vast majority of people I’m emailing are already using Gmail. So it’s kind of pick your battles. If I have something I truly need to keep secure, there are other ways to go about doing that that isn’t Gmail. Mm-hmm. Again, this is where I try to take a very pragmatic approach to all of this. Instead of saying, I’m going to put my tinfoil hat on and I’m going to dial it up to an 11, it’s like, how can I I be 80% good enough with the tools I have available to me that aren’t going to eat up all of my free time?

John: Love it. 2-factor authentication. Where do you— so for people that don’t know what 2-factor authentication is, it’s the idea that you know something and you have something. So you have this thing that’s generating a code that only you have. The code is temporary. It only lasts for a period of time. And you use that in combination with a PIN number or a password or something. That gets you in. What’s your take on that when it comes to password management?

Josh: I use 2-factor auth with my, with my LastPass account, actually. You— they have an app that when I log in, it will basically say, is this you? And then I can click yes or no. And if I click no, obviously I can’t open my, my safe. And I’ve never had to click no.

John: What if you click yes? Does it ask you for something?

Josh: It can, right? I can enter a 3-digit or a 6-digit code, or it pops the app up on my phone and says, like, basically, is this you, right? And, and I love that though, because having the ability to just click a button on my phone is more convenient. And there’s, uh, there’s actually a company that does some of this out there called Duo Security, and they, they have like a 2-factor auth solution. And one of their big claims to fame is the fact that you log in and then it pops up a thing on your phone and says, like, you know, is this you? Should you log in? And you just click yes and everything works, right? You don’t have to type in the 6 digits or whatever.

John: So the idea here is that you have something. You have the phone. Right, exactly. If you lost the phone, you would disable LastPass to say, hey, don’t have that phone anymore. Then that wouldn’t be a valid way to get in.

Josh: Correct. That’s awesome. I love having 2-factor auth in everything I can because, let’s face it, 2-factor auth works. If you look at what’s going on in the universe in terms of password security, Like, use 2-factor auth is probably the single most important and easiest thing you can do in most instances. Now, at the same time though, Google knows less than 10% of people have 2-factor auth enabled on their Google accounts.

John: Aren’t there stupid ways to do 2-factor auth too, like over SMS?

Josh: There are text messages, which the text message network is known to be insecure, and there can be some problems in terms of intercepting this stuff, but here’s my thoughts on this. Using SMS 2-factor auth is better than no 2-factor auth at all.

John: Right. There we go again.

Josh: If you can, don’t use that. But if it’s all you have, that’s better than nothing. And this is one of the great sins I think we end up with in a lot of technology, especially security conversations, is it’s not perfect, so it’s useless. And it’s not binary, right? There’s like a sliding scale, right? It’s not all or nothing. And SMS 2-factor auth is I would put it on the low end of the scale, but it’s still well ahead of no 2-factor auth at all, right?

John: Okay, okay. Now there’s also this thing called—

Josh: Oh man, I love my YubiKeys.

John: And I bought one and I haven’t done it. I was working with someone at work and they were going to show me how to set it up, and we were going to do this massively complex thing just for fun and geekery.

Josh: Which one, which one do you own? Let me ask. There’s like 4 of them.

John: Well, it was the one that was like $40.

Josh: Alright, let me ask you this. If you look at your YubiKey, does it have what looks like a Wi-Fi symbol on it, or does it have a Y on it? Okay, so you have a YubiKey 4. That means probably, um, this is— you bought it probably the last year or two, I would guess. Yeah, yeah. Okay.

John: Yeah, like, that’s very— about a couple months ago. Yeah, it’s a 4. 4 sounds right.

Josh: I actually have 4 YubiKeys. 3 are on my keychain right now. I know, they’re like— I love these things, man. Uh, in fact, the YubiKey people even think I’m crazy when I go talk to to them. But

John: so for the non-geeks out there, the YubiKey is this little like plastic— it’s like, it’s like a thumb drive kind of.

Josh: Yep,

John: that fits on the keychain. It goes into a USB port. And I haven’t really said it. And they’re basically indestructible.

Josh: So actually, you could start using your YubiKey for today, and you should. The thing it does that’s the best is called U2F. And so, uh, like for example, when you log into Gmail U2F, it’s called.

John: U2F.

Josh: And it doesn’t matter what it does. It’s basically— think of it as— whatever, there’s a bunch of technical details that aren’t important, but it’s essentially 2-factor auth. And the idea is this thing you have, so you plug it into your computer. And for example, I do this when I log into Gmail, is I type in my password and then it says plug in your U2F key. I plug my YubiKey in, I tap the button, and it does the magic. of 2-factor auth between the browser and, and the YubiKey. There’s no typing in little codes or anything. And the beauty of U2F is U2F can work on literally an infinite number of sites. So like, for example, if you’re using the YubiKey for what’s called— I’m going to get a little weird— something called HOTP, which is the 6-digit codes it’ll spit out when you push the button, which I’m sure some people might be familiar with.

John: Mm-hmm.

Josh: You can basically do HOTP on a YubiKey for 2 sites max. YubiKey has— think of it as there’s one press of the button, there’s a long press of the button, right? So it kind of has 2 slots, 2 sites. U2F is designed to work with an infinite number essentially. Yeah. And so, for example, I use U2F with Google and Facebook and Twitter and probably Amazon, I think. I don’t even remember how many I have. I just know when a site says plug in your U2F key, I know to stick that thing in and hit the button and I got my 2-factor auth. And it’s amazing.

John: So we’re back to the same principle of something you have. So you have your— the previous example is you have your phone. In this case, you have this little thing called—

Josh: And now here’s where it gets even better though. Here’s where it gets even better though, John. Well, people also— I’m gonna— well, the other beauty of the YubiKey is the things are like indestructible. You can literally like pound them on them with a hammer and you’re not gonna break them. Like, they’re amazing. Uh, but anyway, here’s the best part. So I’ve got my phone, I’ve got my authenticator app on my phone. I generally have— most of these sites let you set up multiple 2-factor auth solutions. So I have one for my phone and I have one for the YubiKey. That gives me the advantage of if I lose my phone, I still have my YubiKey, or if I lose my YubiKey, I still have my phone, right?

John: Oh, this is so great. This brings me back to my original question, though. My phone and my YubiKey are with me with my computer on this airplane that never returns. What does my wife do?

Josh: That’s where LastPass is neat because it has something set up to make this work. And now, now I will say, like, for example, with LastPass, you would not be able to log into like Gmail without using either my YubiKey or my phone. And that’s where it can get tricky, obviously, dealing with family members. However, I know some of these, the important ones, we’ll say like Google or Facebook or whatever, There are ways you can send them documentation to gain access to accounts if needed, for example.

John: Okay, so there’s still— so there is a recovery path, but it’s going to be a little painful.

Josh: It’s going to be a lot painful.

John: Or a lot, we don’t know.

Josh: Let’s face it. And I think of it in the context of if someone steals access to my LastPass vault and can log into my bank, it’s going to be painful for a while, right? It’s sort of the similar thing, but we’re also talking about this is a catastrophic event. This is the Category 5 hurricane is what we’re talking about here, something that you basically just can’t plan for.

John: Yeah, and I guess I’m torn on that one because I know situations where a family member suddenly passes away and they want to get to that person’s contacts or their email to find out who they should tell about the memorial service or whatever. So then you’re going to want to be kind.

Josh: And that’s something that I, I think as a human it’s worth considering, right? If, if that’s a concern you have, like if you’re like me and you just— well, just, yeah, don’t have friends, right? Or just don’t have friends. If you’re mean to everybody, you don’t have any friends. It’s so much easier, right?

John: Big takeaway from today’s conversation.

Josh: That’s right, it simplifies so many things. That’s right, that’s right. Nobody likes me, no one’s coming to my funeral, Joan. It’s fine, problem solved. Okay.

John: That’s— yeah.

Josh: Well, in— so here’s the thing, right, is you’re not wrong, but you have to draw a line when you’re thinking about the what-ifs. If that’s something that’s important to you, you put it below the line. If it’s something that’s not important to you, you put it above the line. Like in my— like for example, in my case, I’ve never printed off like a list of people I would want my wife to contact if I was suddenly killed, and I don’t want to. I’m not going to lie to you. I feel like the people who would need to know would figure it out in their own way, and I’m not that concerned about it. In all seriousness, here’s a great example. If something happens to me, there are certain people that I’m connected to on Facebook or Twitter that would probably send something out saying, hey, Josh got hit by a runaway bus, or something. I have a suspicion the word would spread quickly amongst the people who would be interested in this news. And so that’s kind of— that’s just the way I envision it, is like, don’t care. And let’s face it too, it’s not going to be my problem. So I’ll just— Right, right. But I mean, again, it’s— I value my time, and so I just don’t want to deal with some of this stuff because it can— I remember, I remember thinking like this, and it can become one of those just unattainable problems where it’s like, oh, this, but now what about this, and now what about this? And there’s actually— there’s a great intro to A Malcolm in the Middle episode where the dad, who ended up selling meth later on in life I guess, but the dad, he was going to change a light bulb and then he went to get the light bulbs and the door didn’t open. The door was stuck. Then he went to get tools and the tools were in the wrong spot. You know what I mean? He ended up changing the oil in his car by the end of it. His wife is like, Hal, change the light bulb. He’s like, I’m working on it. Right? That’s what I feel like this stuff turns into. Where you— right, it’s seriously though. I mean, that’s beautiful. You do this and then, oh, but what about that? And what about that? And what about that? And, and this is where I feel like I’m trying very hard to make decisions about if I do this, does it really matter? And if the, if I— if the answer isn’t a hard yes, then just forget it. Like, get rid of it.

John: So bring this, bring this kind of full circle. So you’re gonna pick A service— the 2 that we’ve talked about is LastPass or 1Password— you are— if you’re sharing it with someone, you’re gonna do— like, if with my wife, so she’s gonna have her own. We’re gonna sign up for the family plan or whatever, and she will have her own way to get in.

Josh: So actually, it’s even cooler than that. So the way LastPass Family works— and I can only speak of this one because obviously it’s what I use— so, so I have a family, right? And I have my wife, me, and, and my son. are part of this family. I can pick the passwords that are shared with the people. So for example, my son’s password for— we’ll just say his Blizzard account because that’s basically the only one he has. It’s like the games, right?

John: What’s Blizzard?

Josh: The Blizzard gaming company. He plays Overwatch, that’s the name of the game. Totally kicks my butt at it. It’s sad. I’ve reached that point now where I’m losing to my kids at video games. We’re playing Minecraft.

John: Does this beat on Minecraft?

Josh: I can’t really lose at Minecraft. Anyway, anyway, so I can say that my wife and my son and myself have access to this password. I can say my wife has access to these other passwords. I can say only I have access to these passwords. Then I can also say that my wife is kind of like the emergency contact. So what happens is she can request by LastPass and say, I need emergency access to Josh’s stuff. And then LastPass sends a thing to me and says, your wife is requesting emergency access. Can we give it to her? And I can obviously click no. And the intent here is that if I’m not dead, I’m going to click no, right? But if I’m dead, I can’t click no. And then I set it up so in 2 days she gains access because I figure if I don’t have access to email for 2 days, something terrible has probably happened to me, right? And she’s going to need access to this stuff. And it’s super cool. And you can set up then— basically anyone you want to be your emergency backup for the password information, which is— it’s awesome, man. It is. And again, I know there’s a certain amount of risk that comes with this, but I would rather accept that risk than deal with the old tinfoil hat way I was doing that was, let’s face it, so error-prone, there was probably no way it was going to be done correctly. And funny enough, it’s product management that really opened my eyes to that. It’s basically if anything has more than 2 steps in it, it’s going to fail. Let’s just face it, right? In terms of expecting users to get it right or developers developers to get it right, or, or like documentation to explain it. No matter what group it is, if there’s more than 2 steps, it’s too many steps.

John: OK, so get a password manager, set up some type of emergency or shared thing, set up 2-factor authentication, whether with a YubiKey, your phone, something. Any other considerations around password management?

Josh: In all seriousness, if you do those 2 things, that will probably put you into the top 80% of secure users on the internet. That sounds silly, but seriously, those 2 things will make more of a difference in keeping your data and your account safe than anything else you can do. I know, man. It’s crazy to think about, but for real. These aren’t hard things to do, but part of the challenge also is how do you know? How do you know which— how would someone know to do this? I’ll think of my parents as a great example. How would they know this? They have no idea, right? They know this because I made them do it, but I mean—

John: You use that password reminder, that thing that remembers passwords in your web browser. That’s where you do it, right?

Josh: In all seriousness, I don’t have a problem with that necessarily, except people type in their passwords. Really? They’re crappy passwords. You need the auto-generated password. That’s really the magic of it. Yeah.

John: Any other general— while we’ve got you here, any other things that you would share at your presentations for non-security people that general people listening to this might want to know or could be helpful to them, things they should explore?

Josh: Get a Chromebook. No, actually, and also I have one. I use it when I travel to security conferences, for real. So this is the other thing that I think is happening is we’re entering the golden age of client computing where you have your iPads and you have your Chromebooks and you have your Android tablets and all this stuff. And these little devices, because of the way they kind of came into the world, they have amazing security built into them. I mean, there’s a reason you hear about the FBI complaining about getting into an iPhone because Apple got the security on that thing right. Breaking into your MacBook, not hard. Breaking into your iPhone, probably impossible. So yeah, in all seriousness, using things like iPads and tablets and Chromebooks are huge in terms of your security, especially when you’re traveling. But at the same time, obviously, they’re fairly limiting, so you have to keep that in mind as well. But yeah, I mean, in all seriousness, if I’m giving out advice to people, it’s basically get an iPhone, get a Chromebook, password manager, and 2-factor auth. That’s probably 95% right there.

John: This is a tangent, but I’ve always wondered about this. Dropbox. Is there a secure way to store stuff on Dropbox? Because my understanding is that stuff that you store there, it’s not encrypted, so someone working at Dropbox can see your stuff.

Josh: The better question is, do you care? The answer is no. There’s basically no way. If you care, then don’t store it on Dropbox. Let’s face it though, there’s probably not a really good place you can put it. Here’s my attitude on this as well is I don’t care. If you want to look at my files, Dropbox engineer, go ahead. There’s nothing there that’s useful.

John: Where I’m going with this is I’ve been doing a lot of personal development work with people. Some of this information is really personal to them. I saw a coach the other day on a public forum saying, oh, I store all my stuff on Dropbox because it’s really secure.

Josh: That’s a great example, actually. There’s something coming out called GDPR, the global— I don’t even remember the name of it now. Man, I’ve been doing so much with this. Anyway, in Europe, basically, they’re starting to put rules on how you can deal with personal information. That’s a great example, actually. I don’t have a good answer for you today. how to store, you know, personal information on someone else that would be probably dangerous or embarrassing if it got out. And I can tell you now, don’t, don’t put it on Dropbox. Heck no.

John: Right. No. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So that’s what kind of raised it for me because I’ve, I’ve been looking, you know, there’s all kinds of hacky ways to do it, but they all look like, um, someone was talking about setting up a TrueCrypt volume and But then it’s like, what if the volume gets correct— corrupted? And it’s just like, what a mess,

Josh: right? And, and that— but, but again, when you’re dealing with things like personal information about someone else, like my own stuff is different in my opinion because that’s, that’s my thing, right? Exactly. But when it’s someone else, that’s where it becomes very challenging, right? And that’s— I don’t have a good answer for that today. I mean, I’m not gonna lie to you. Yeah, it’s— I don’t know. I don’t know what to tell you.

John: Any other services Any other services you like? Like, say, for VPN? I heard you mention— I listened to your episode about VPNs, and you did not name your provider.

Josh: Oh, did I not?

John: Who is it?

Josh: I don’t know. I use something called iPredator. It’s kind of mysterious.

John: iPredator.

Josh: Yeah, it’s not meant to be mysterious. It’s, uh, they’re the, the guys who created the Pirate Bay created this VPN service. And my, my view on it is, if, if I’m going to expect anyone to give the finger to any government coming around knocking, it’s probably those guys.

John: So, and VPN, by the way, for those that are not in the know, so VPN is the idea that if you’re not at home, or even if you are, I guess, if you’re on a Wi-Fi network that’s not secure, like you’re at the airport or something, people can watch your traffic. If you’re running a VPN, it protects it some more. Is it 100% guaranteed that it’s protected? As Josh has said, no, but it’s better than nothing. We’re back to that.

Josh: And, and for VPN providers, it’s Just look around. There are so many now. Honestly, back when I signed up with these guys, there weren’t a lot of good ones. That’s one of the reasons. I keep meaning to spend some time finding a new one, but, again, I value my time, so I haven’t reached the point yet where the return on that investment will justify itself.

John: For some reason, that stuck in my head because you told a funny story about how they were in another country and it’s a foreign currency transaction and your credit card calls you once a year when you pay them. I don’t know. For some reason, it stuck in my head.

Josh: Yes, yes, yes. And, and it is there. I think they’re in Sweden or Switzerland. I forget which country. Uh, but yeah, yeah, it’s— I love it. Anyway, I, I can’t think of anything else, John.

John: Well, thanks for stopping by, and I love your approach. Yeah, pragmatic, not so black and white. So thank you.

Josh: Awesome, man. It was fun. Until next time.